×
〈 〉

The Woman Who Spent Decades Running a Lighthouse


The Woman Who Spent Decades Running a Lighthouse


1795128616be7d28389a161d54d0f6fc8381fa7afe9147c670.jpegBrodie Miller on Pexels

Harriet Colfax was teaching piano and voice when she got a job running a lighthouse in 1861. She was thirty-seven, and the light stood on a stretch of Indiana shoreline where Lake Michigan could turn nasty without much warning. Every evening meant carrying lamp oil up a tower, no matter what the weather was doing. There were no weekends off, either.

She kept the job for forty-three years, finally retiring at eighty as the longest-serving female lighthouse keeper on the Great Lakes. For all those years, she shared the keeper's quarters with Ann Hartwell, a schoolteacher who had moved west with her. Locals grew so used to seeing Harriet at work that they started calling the place Little Miss Colfax's Light. Her dependability also earned the station another nickname: Old Faithful.

She Got The Job Through Her Cousin

Having a well-connected relative certainly helped. Harriet's cousin Schuyler Colfax was a congressman in 1861 and would go on to become Speaker of the House and vice president under Ulysses S. Grant. Newspapers writing about Harriet over the next forty years generally assumed he had helped her get the appointment. It was the sort of political favor that raised few eyebrows at the time. Schuyler's own career later fell apart in a railroad bribery scandal, but that's another story.

Harriet had moved to Michigan City in 1853 with her brother Richard, who was starting a newspaper. Ann Hartwell came along and found work teaching school. The two women had known each other back in New York and would share a home for decades. When Harriet got the lighthouse job, Ann moved into the keeper's quarters with her. It remained their home throughout Harriet's working life.

Whatever connections got her hired, the government ended up with a keeper who served under ten presidents. The brick tower stood thirty-nine feet tall, with a lens powerful enough to send light fifteen miles across Lake Michigan. Harriet had to light the lamp at dusk and put it out again at dawn, every single day. The schedule didn't change because she was sick or the weather was awful.

The Work Was Worse Than It Sounds

For much of her career, the lamps burned lard oil, which thickened or solidified in cold weather. Harriet had to warm it on a stove before carrying it out to the lights. Sometimes it cooled and thickened again before she reached them, forcing her to turn around and start over. Given what Indiana winters are like along Lake Michigan, that must have happened more often than she cared to remember.

She also had two lights to look after. One was in the main tower onshore, while the other stood at the end of the east pier. Reaching that second lamp meant walking along a raised wooden catwalk that became dangerously icy in winter. Harriet made the trip carrying oil anyway. In October 1886, a powerful gale swept the pierhead beacon away altogether. After it was rebuilt, she continued making that walk for another eighteen years.

Sometimes Harriet had an assistant keeper, but there were also stretches when she managed without one. By most accounts, she preferred to light the lamps herself regardless. After the federal government began requiring written logs in 1872, she kept a daily record of conditions at the station. Roughly thirty years of those entries survive, most of them brief notes about the weather. It's a lot of ordinary evenings written down by someone who couldn't afford to miss one.

She Stayed Forty-Three Years

Michigan City grew up around Harriet while she kept tending the same lights. The town had 3,320 residents when she arrived at the lighthouse, and by 1900 that number had climbed to 14,850. What had been a small harbor was becoming a busy industrial port. The equipment changed, too. Eventually, the old lard oil was replaced with a fuel that stayed liquid in cold weather, though Harriet had already spent more than twenty winters wrestling with the original system.

She finally retired in 1904 at the age of eighty. A Chicago newspaper that year described her as the oldest and most reliable lighthouse keeper in the country. Her logbook records her selling off household belongings that October as she prepared to leave what she called the "dear old lighthouse." Even her final entry, written four days later, was mostly business as usual. She mentioned the weather and someone who had stopped by to visit.

Harriet died the following year. The old lighthouse is still standing in Michigan City, where the local historical society now operates it as a museum. Visitors can walk through the rooms Harriet and Ann called home for more than four decades. Nine keepers held the Michigan City post during its working life, but Harriet remains the one people remember. Nobody else spent quite so many years keeping its light burning.