×
〈 〉

20 Royal Children Whose Parentage Became A National Scandal


20 Royal Children Whose Parentage Became A National Scandal


Paternity Was A Matter Of State

In royal families, a question about who fathered a child could turn into a fight over the throne. Rivals were quick to spread rumors, especially when an heir stood between them and the crown. Some accusations were invented to ruin reputations, while others had enough truth behind them to threaten entire dynasties. Modern DNA testing has cleared up a few mysteries and raised new questions about others. Here are 20 royal children whose parentage caused a national scandal.

17952213507b1cd19538b6ccc823fbf87532fceea0c79278f1.jpgUnknown, possibly after Willem Wissing. on Wikimedia

Advertisement

1. Edward IV Was Rumored to Be an Archer's Son

Rumors that Edward IV was really the son of an archer named Blaybourne surfaced during a rebellion against him in 1469. His brother George repeated the story after his arrest in 1477, and it resurfaced in 1483 as Richard III made his case for the throne. Historians have mostly treated it as a political smear.

1795221177cf5aa8ec6e97812ec6cd576c780f2c57b1a47120.jpganonymous  on Wikimedia

Advertisement

2. Juana la Beltraneja Lost a Crown to the Gossip

Henry IV of Castile's enemies claimed his daughter Juana was fathered by the royal favorite Beltrán de la Cueva and nicknamed her la Beltraneja. When Henry died in 1474, nobles split between Juana and her aunt Isabella, and the four-year war that followed ended with Juana in exile in Portugal.

17952212093822b6a0407367ff4a7f2292aaafbdea0a333637.jpgUnknown authorUnknown author (French art) on Wikimedia

Advertisement

3. Mary Boleyn's Children May Have Been Henry VIII's

Mary Boleyn was Henry VIII's mistress before her sister Anne married him, and her children Catherine and Henry Carey were born during her marriage to William Carey. A vicar hostile to the Boleyns claimed young Henry was the king's son, and later writers noted the royal grants William Carey received around each birth. Henry VIII never acknowledged either child.

179522122757376010e81c7a031650b923c7b10f748628b24c.jpgUnknown authorUnknown author on Wikimedia

Advertisement

4. James VI Was Called the Son of a Murdered Secretary

Mary, Queen of Scots, was six months pregnant in 1566 when her husband Lord Darnley and a group of nobles killed her secretary David Rizzio in front of her. The killers accused Rizzio of fathering the child. Decades later, Henry IV of France mocked James's reputation as the Scottish Solomon by saying he hoped James wasn't the son of David the fiddler.

1795221268dd277db07c9d1f335c299c77abae1fac1d3e73c8.pngJohn de Critz on Wikimedia

Advertisement

5. Louis XIV Arrived After 23 Years of Waiting

Louis XIV was born after his parents had been married for 23 years, so he was christened Louis-Dieudonné, meaning God-given. One modern biographer argues that Louis resembled Cardinal Mazarin more than Louis XIII in looks and ability, though nothing has ever proved it.

17952212893e0a29ad3aef0dd381ee5e6a2ce29b02fae1019e.jpgClaude Lefèbvre / Formerly attributed to Philippe de Champaigne on Wikimedia

Advertisement

6. Monmouth Claimed His Parents Had Secretly Married

Charles II acknowledged James Scott, his son with Lucy Walter, and made him Duke of Monmouth in 1663. Protestants who feared Charles's Catholic brother later claimed Charles had secretly married Lucy, with the proof hidden in a black box. Charles publicly denied ever marrying anyone but the queen, and no box turned up (one crowd at a 1685 election paraded a box on a pole to mock the idea).

1795221337fb2a51ea01357331b59856bf13643675f168ef14.jpganonymous  on Wikimedia

Advertisement

7. James Francis Edward Stuart Was Called the Warming-Pan Baby

After losing her previous children in infancy, Mary of Modena gave birth to a healthy son in June 1688. The prospect of a Catholic heir alarmed Protestants, who claimed the real baby had died and a replacement was smuggled in using a warming pan. Even the boy's half-sister, Princess Anne, may have helped spread the rumor. James II published testimony from more than 70 witnesses, but few were convinced. 

17952214184213d3f2d4d60e70558d2b2eceb769732ac72e99.jpgNicolas de Largillière on Wikimedia

Advertisement

8. Catherine the Great Hinted That Paul I Wasn't Peter's Son

Catherine the Great suggested in her memoirs that her lover Sergei Saltykov had fathered her son Paul. In a later edition she reversed herself and named her husband Peter as the father. Paul grew up stocky and quarrelsome like Peter and looked very little like the tall, handsome Saltykov.

17952214377e24da80339f9a7db76d38b4956f0a6df4e1e2fe.jpgAfter Alexander Roslin on Wikimedia

Advertisement

9. Louise Augusta Was Called La Petite Struensee

Queen Caroline Matilda of Denmark fell in love with Johann Friedrich Struensee, the physician who effectively ran the country for her mentally ill husband. Her daughter Louise Augusta was born in 1771, and courtiers called the girl la petite Struensee. Struensee was executed in 1772, and the queen was divorced and banished. Christian VII still recognized Louise Augusta as his own daughter.

1795221459c47523754c6ffb12e3a65336454db22bedc3c886.jpgHelfrich Peter Sturz on Wikimedia

Advertisement

10. Gustav IV Adolf's Birth Split the Swedish Royal Family

Gustav III and Queen Sophia Magdalena went more than a decade without consummating their marriage, so the king asked his equerry Adolf Fredrik Munck to coach them. When the future Gustav IV Adolf was born in 1778, rumors named Munck as the father, and the king's own mother questioned the baby's legitimacy in what became known as the Munck Affair.

17952217693922f98d6a9e1cd03af9bf374200c4ae97068328.jpgPer Krafft the Younger on Wikimedia

Advertisement

11. Napoleon III's DNA Didn't Match His Uncle's

Hortense de Beauharnais had a miserable marriage to Louis Bonaparte, and gossip named a Dutch admiral as the real father of her son Napoleon III. A DNA study published in 2013 found that Napoleon III's Y chromosome belonged to a different paternal line from Napoleon I's. The break could trace back to Hortense or to Louis's own mother, so the study doesn't say who the father was.

17952217967bfbbd19a47f0009a32346e8abc001967d9c5259.jpgFranz Xaver Winterhalter on Wikimedia

Advertisement

12. Kaspar Hauser Was Rumored to Be a Stolen Prince

Kaspar Hauser turned up in Nuremberg in 1828 as a teenager who said he had grown up alone in a dark cell. A popular theory held that he was the true heir of Baden, swapped as a baby for a dying infant. In 2024 researchers compared his mitochondrial DNA with the House of Baden's line and ruled that theory out.

1795221816d500a75184b247fc190906722561578c516df1e1.jpgJohann Lorenz Kreul on Wikimedia

Advertisement

13. Alfonso XII Was Nicknamed After His Supposed Father

Isabella II's husband, Francisco de Asís, was widely rumored to be impotent, and gossip named a guard captain called Enrique Puigmoltó as the real father of her son Alfonso. Opponents nicknamed the boy Puigmoltejo. He became king anyway in 1874, six years after a revolution had sent his mother into exile.

179522183528686ecd48f4a8726924a3ec6b84e4cbb6827a80.jpgUnknown authorUnknown author on Wikimedia

Advertisement

14. Anna Anderson Said She Was Anastasia

A young woman in a Berlin hospital began claiming in the early 1920s that she was Grand Duchess Anastasia, the murdered tsar's youngest daughter. A 1927 investigation identified her as Franziska Schanzkowska, a Polish factory worker, and she spent decades losing court cases as Anna Anderson. DNA tests in 1994 showed she wasn't related to the Romanovs and matched a great-nephew of Schanzkowska.

17952218623b467fd8fab170a5a634810ca5b42064fc15c081.jpgUnknown authorUnknown author on Wikimedia

Advertisement

15. Leopold II Gave His Sons Titles He Never Made Official

Leopold II was in his 60s when he met Blanche Delacroix, a young Paris courtesan, and they had two sons he called the Duke of Tervuren and the Count of Ravenstein. No royal decree ever made those titles official. Leopold married Blanche in a religious ceremony days before his death in 1909, and the marriage had no validity under Belgian law.

1795221889c2cc89981d4a7d58da7e21d8ea7a2eb74a1244bb.jpgUnidentified painter on Wikimedia

Advertisement

16. Carol Lambrino Fought for Decades to Be Called Legitimate

Crown Prince Carol of Romania married Zizi Lambrino in 1918 without his father's consent, and Romania's Supreme Court annulled the marriage the next year. Their son, born in 1920, was treated as illegitimate and raised in exile in France. A Portuguese court recognized him as Carol II's legitimate son in 1955, and a Romanian court followed in 1995.

1795221910d20cdf70aa4455c79d5870c31366b772a0be6e9f.jpgUnknown authorUnknown author on Wikimedia

Advertisement

17. Prince Bernhard Revealed Two Daughters After His Death

Two weeks after Prince Bernhard of the Netherlands died in 2004, a newspaper published interviews in which he said he had six daughters, two of them born outside his marriage to Queen Juliana. His French daughter Alexia Grinda was already an open secret. Alicia von Bielefeld, born in San Francisco in 1952, surprised nearly everyone.

1795221927f722e6d4e598ca80aa1da49dd123597e03ed3dc8.jpgYousuf Karsh on Wikimedia

Advertisement

18. Delphine Boël Sued a Former King to Prove He Was Her Father

Reports that Belgian artist Delphine Boël was King Albert II's daughter began circulating in 1997, and Albert denied it for years. She sued him after he abdicated in 2013, and a court ordered a DNA test. Albert conceded in January 2020, and that October a Brussels appeal court ruled she could call herself Princess Delphine of Belgium.

179522194294acf13e1fad8025236620db7b02dcbdbb9cbb93.jpgLuc Van Braekel on Wikimedia

Advertisement

19. Jazmin Grace Grimaldi Waited 14 Years for Recognition

A California woman named Tamara Rotolo said in 1992 that Prince Albert of Monaco had fathered her newborn daughter, Jazmin. Albert confirmed it in June 2006, after a DNA test, when Jazmin was 14. Because her parents never married, she is excluded from the throne.

179522199702aa629c8b16cd17a44f3a0efec2feed43937642.jpgDavid.deshayes on Wikimedia

Advertisement

20. Leandro de Borbón Went to Court to Prove He Was Alfonso XIII's Son

Leandro Ruiz Moragas was born in 1929 to Alfonso XIII and his longtime mistress, the actress Carmen Ruiz Moragas, and grew up with his mother's surnames. In 2003, at 74, he won a ruling from Madrid's civil registry declaring him the king's son and letting him use the surname Borbón. He then claimed the title of infante as a king's son, though Spain never granted it.

17952224318af5b47ff74caa3cf485ed11495b984029497db5.jpgKaulak on Wikimedia

Advertisement